Prince Street Pizza

Edna Banks

3 weeks ago

My friend and I decided to create our own little pizza tour and try out a few of the pizza places in the Village/LES area that were allegedly the best pizza. Based on the reviews, I put Prince Street Pizza on our list. We both got a slice of the pepperoni square. We got there at about 7:00 on a Friday night and waited in line for approximately 20 minutes.This pizza is ABSOLUTELY incredible! I’m not generally a fan of the thick crust pizza, but this was so delicious and amazing. The sauce itself was sweet, but the pepperoni was spicy. It was a perfect balance. Already dying to go back!

Andrew Dabydeen

a month ago

Definitely a solid pizza slice but $4.50? Definitely other options that are better in NYC. If you’re in the area and don’t want to travel far, this is your place. But if you’re in the scenario where you want to find some truly amazing pizza, definitely other options out there. I’ll be back if I need a slice that’s good but definitely on the pricey side. I’d still recommend if you haven’t had a slice from here yet.

Eric Xu

a month ago

Love this place. I'm from out of town and this is by far my favorite pizza places in terms of flavor. I only tried a pepperoni slice however it was the best flavored pepperonis I've ever had. It was a square pizza aka Sicilian? Couldn't tell much on cheese but I'm not a cheese guy in general. Pizza was also kind of thick, not as thick as normal "deep dish" but thick for sure. Dough was not bad. One slice was a very good amount. Highly recommend to try at least once! Place was small, no seating just a bar stand sort of from one side of the wall.

Daniel Jordan

3 weeks ago

I work in the area and have walked by this place many times and seen a long line, I've never stopped. Today I did. The pepperoni square slice was good, but not great. Extremely greasy which is to be expected with pepperoni I suppose. I think the long lines are a result of them being pretty slow as opposed to them being very good. I found the crust to be quite soggy and didn't care for the texture. also, I purchased two slices of the same pizza one was literally twice the size of the other. At the price, I felt like the larger of the two was a fair price for the size. The smaller of the two was quite small for the price. The slice pictured is the larger of the two.

Dustin U

a week ago

Plain cheese slice was very good. Square Sicilian pepperoni was definitely worth the stop. The margarita pizza as you can see was a little burnt. I definitely stop by to have the squares Sicilian pepperoni.